In the world of midsize trucks, durability and off-road capability are crucial features for those who venture into the great outdoors. In this article, we'll pit three popular models against each other in a battle of wits, or rather, a battle of traction. The Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road, Ford Ranger FX4, and Chevrolet Colorado Z71 are all contenders in this off-road showdown, but which one will emerge victorious?

Introduction

The midsize truck market has experienced a significant surge in recent years, with manufacturers competing fiercely to offer the best combination of on-road refinement and off-road prowess. While the top-of-the-line models often get the most attention, it's the midgrade trims that offer a more affordable and practical solution for those who need a capable workhorse without breaking the bank. In this comparison test, we'll put the Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road, Ford Ranger FX4, and Chevrolet Colorado Z71 through their paces to determine which one is the best off-road performer in its class.

The Terrain

Our test route took us through a variety of challenging off-road terrain, including steep hills, rocky inclines, and sandy washes. Each truck was equipped with its standard off-road suspension and tires, with no modifications or upgrades. This allowed us to evaluate the trucks in their most practical and affordable configurations.

The Test

First up was the Ziggurat of Integrity, a steep and rocky incline that demanded precise control and traction. The Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road handled this section with ease, its four-wheel drive system and locking rear differential providing the necessary grip to navigate the rocky terrain. The Ford Ranger FX4 was close behind, its terrain management system helping to transfer power to the wheels that needed it most. The Chevrolet Colorado Z71 struggled on this section, its rear wheels spinning wildly as it struggled to find traction.

Next, we tackled the Hill Climb, a long and grueling incline that tested the trucks' engines and transmissions. The Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road performed admirably, its V6 engine providing a smooth and consistent supply of power. The Ford Ranger FX4 was also impressive, its 2.3-liter turbocharged engine delivering plenty of grunt to tackle the incline. The Chevrolet Colorado Z71 lagged behind, its 3.6-liter V6 engine struggling to keep up with the pace.

The Pipes

The Sand Wash Circuit was a challenging section that required the trucks to navigate a series of tight turns and sandy washes. The Ford Ranger FX4 excelled on this section, its terrain management system helping to reduce wheel spin and maintain traction. The Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road was also impressive, its four-wheel drive system and locking rear differential providing the necessary grip to tackle the sandy terrain. The Chevrolet Colorado Z71 struggled on this section, its rear wheels spinning wildly as it struggled to find traction.

Alternatives to Consider

If you're in the market for a capable midsize truck, but these three models don't quite fit your needs, here are some alternative options to consider:

Chevrolet Colorado ZR2: A more aggressive off-road trim with a higher ground clearance and more advanced suspension.

Ford Ranger Raptor: A high-performance off-road trim with a more powerful engine and more advanced suspension.

Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro: A more aggressive off-road trim with a higher ground clearance and more advanced suspension.

Edmunds' Take

After putting these three midsize trucks through their paces, it's clear that the Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road is the winner in this off-road showdown. Its combination of four-wheel drive, locking rear differential, and terrain management system make it the most capable and confident performer on challenging off-road terrain. While the Ford Ranger FX4 and Chevrolet Colorado Z71 are both close behind, they struggle to match the Tacoma's level of traction and control.

Final Verdict

In conclusion, the Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road is the best off-road performer in its class, with its combination of four-wheel drive, locking rear differential, and terrain management system making it the most capable and confident performer on challenging off-road terrain. While the Ford Ranger FX4 and Chevrolet Colorado Z71 are both close behind, they struggle to match the Tacoma's level of traction and control. If you're in the market for a capable midsize truck, the Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-Road is the clear winner.

Where to Buy